Weber vs Char-Broil BBQ Gas Grills Comparison, Reviews, Ratings

Weber and Char-broil are two of the most well-known brands out there, but is one better than the other? Ultimately, they do the same thing but some of the features differ, and it’s important to look out for what works for you.

Below we’ve looked at both brands, compared their most popular products and given you a useful breakdown to help you decide which is the best grill for you.

Char-Broil Grills

This brand belongs to the longstanding WC Bradley co. which made their first cast iron bbq in 1949 under their sub company Iron Works. The production was transferred to a new factory in 1973, and their gas grills line was given the name Char-broil. So, you can be confident that this company has a proud heritage in making gas grills and BBQs of the highest quality and caliber.

Weber Grills

It was in the year 1952 that George Stephen who was an employee at Weber decided to embark on his own creative journey. Slicing a marine buoy down the middle, he drilled some vent holes and added legs to one half and thus the Weber grill was invented. The main attractive feature of this grill was the dome shape which would protect the grilling food from rain when cooking outdoors, so it could be used in all weathers by enthusiastic grillers.

Due to the effectiveness of this initial design, the grill was subsequently developed and a series of features have been added over the years – including metal flavor bars which provided better heat and flavor distribution, and other heat control mechanisms which kept the grill safe, yet effective. These design features were quite revolutionary and some say contributed to the current design of new modern gas grills on the market.

Char-Broil vs. Weber Grills Comparison


Char-Broil Classic 280 2-Burner Liquid Propane Gas Grill with Side Burner

  • Cooking space: 280 square inch
  • Fuel Type: Propane Gas
  • Grill type: 2 burners, 20000 BTU-per-hour
  • 8000 BTU side burner
  • Grates: Porcelain coated wire
  • Plastic side shelves are useful for storing tools.
  • Porcelain coated steel lid and firebox
  • Wheels for mobility
  • Piezo ignition system

Weber 45010001 Black Spirit II E-310 LP Gas Grill

  • Cooking space: 280 square inches
  • Fuel Type: Propane Gas
  • Grill type: 2 stainless steel in-line burners 30, 000 BTU-per-hour
  • Wheels for mobility
  • Porcelain-coated steel lid and firebox which are durable and weather worthy
  • Metal side shelves providing extra storage and prep space

Which is Better?


Price

Price and budget influence most people’s purchases. In this instance, the Char-Broil is more attractive at almost a third of the price of the Weber. The Weber features, however, are more impressive. As outlined below, the material is more robust and durable, it is easier to clean, and it can be moved around safely and efficiently. For more details, you can loot gas grills at under $300 and under $200.

Construction

While they appear to be quite robust and sturdy, Char-Broil grills are made of type 430 steel which is prone to rust. In comparison to this, Weber grills are stronger and higher quality and are in fact designed to withstand all weather conditions.

Cleaning

In terms of cleaning, Weber grills are arguably easier to clean. This is because the grease is designed to fall into aluminum tins which are underneath the grill. These are easily removable for cleaning and replacing. This process keeps the grease off your hands. Unfortunately, Char-Broil grills require manual cleaning of the grease from a box beneath the burner. This can be a messy process.

Both grills have wheels which make them easy to move around. The Char-Broil wheels are plastic, and the Weber is fitted with casters that are weather-resistant.

Our Take

The Char-Broil Classic 280 grill is perfect for hosting a small group of friends to a bbq. It only needs a few minutes to heat up, saving the time that usually needs to be spent on a  traditional bbq. The 20000 BTU-per-hour burners make more quick and efficient cooking, while the additional 8000 BTU side burner is convenient for cooking up more delicate side dishes or warming sauces.

It has a useful design with 2 side shelves which made it easy for me to store tools and ingredients. The 2 wheels make is easily transportable too. Safe moving of a grill is vitality important for obvious reasons. I found the ignition system to be reliable was impressed with the excellent searing power when cooking. After multiple uses and being kept out in all weathers, my Char-Broil is yet to show any rust. This is a testament to its weatherproof design.

When testing the Weber grill, I found it delivers solid performance. It’s easy to use, easy to clean, and sturdy – making it a great investment for bbq parties large and small. It comes in a variety of attractive colors including black, ivory, red, sapphire and mocha – a level of choice which I appreciated.

No matter what I was grilling, the 30000 BTU burners and battery powered ignition never let me down, but the lack of a side burner is certainly disappointing. However, the ease of cleaning is one of my favorite features. I like how it saves time since it just requires emptying of the aluminum trays, without any unpleasant scrubbing required.

Just like the Char-Broil, the wheels also make it easily transportable which I believe to be important for an appliance such as this.

Overall, the power and ease of use of the Weber make it my top pick. It simply has more user-friendly features compared to the Charbroil. This is all reflected in their differing price tags since Weber grills are a lot more expensive. But if you want the best of a good bunch, I would recommend the Weber 45010001 as the winner of this race.

Leave a Comment